Producer prices were flat as was the US dollar index, but that didn’t stop a determined seller from pushing gold prices down this morning.
What is driving the selling pressure?
Most traders are paid to execute orders to maximize value. That is to say, if you are selling a commodity you want to sell it for the highest price (or short it at the highest price) to maximize your profits.
What we’ve seen within the last several years is the opposite of that. Regular dumping of gold (and silver) futures contracts with heavy volume at the lowest prices. Huge lots executed at once — rather than distributed over the course of a day to achieve a volume average weighted price.
Are prices being fixed?
This leads the gold investing community to believe that there is malicious manipulation underway in these markets. And with just about every other market in the world having been proven to be manipulated, such as LIBOR, foreign exchange, bonds, equities and other commodities — perhaps, just perhaps it’s not too paranoid of a theory after all.
A reason to sell so many contracts in to the market at once would be to push price down through sell stop orders.
This action forces prices even lower and pushes many out of long positions.
Only the people pushing the sell button truly know their own intentions (or that of the institution they are employed by). An outside observer of these markets is forced to draw their own conclusions.
How can so many claim to own the same gold?
The ratio of futures contracts to ounces of physical gold at the COMEX has risen to the highest levels on record. Last checked, it was closing in on 250 gold futures claims per ounce of physical gold actually available. This means that should there be a large demand for COMEX gold delivery, there may not be the gold available to fulfill the order — necessitating a cash settlement.
If one was seeking delivery to obtain physical metal for storage, this would force that party to seek gold elsewhere as soon as possible with that settled cash. And given that so many parties seem to have claims on the same ounces of gold, that could prove to be an interesting setup for a phenomenal short squeeze that drives prices much, much higher.
Potential scenarios for the continued decline.
How this particular situation resolves remains a mystery, but I am inclined to speculate that we have two possible scenarios that could play out:
1: We are witnessing the beginning of the one of the greatest deflationary collapses the world has ever seen, as evidenced by commodity prices imploding, China’s economy in serious decline and recent volatility in equity markets. If this is the case then it will be difficult to find a safe home for one’s money almost anywhere.
2: The precious metals markets’ prices are being guided lower in order to reduce the bid for what were once considered safe haven assets by many. Eventually, if such a scheme is underway, it will unravel with prices going much higher.
Which of these scenarios is playing out remains to be realized.
The former means the global markets are coming unglued at the seams and the global economy is crushed. The latter would indicate that certain parties are concerned that a higher gold price could reduce confidence in other markets such as stocks and bonds.